When a raccoon moves into your attic or starts raiding your garbage cans, trapping it is usually the fastest solution. But raccoons are highly intelligent, naturally cautious, and have an incredible sense of smell. If you bait a trap incorrectly, they will either steal the bait without triggering the trap or ignore it completely.
The Bottom Line: The absolute best bait for raccoons is a strong-smelling sweet cherry pellet (like Coon Gitter) or a large marshmallow. If you want to lure them from a distance, a fish oil-based scent is the most powerful attractant. However, if you want to avoid catching neighborhood cats, stick strictly to berry or sweet-based baits.
Here is the professional field guide on how to select, place, and use the best raccoon baits for 2026. For a complete overview of removing and excluding wildlife, see our Complete Rodent & Wildlife Control Guide.
Trapping Rules: Placement Beats Bait Every Time
You can buy the most expensive bait on the market, but if you don’t follow these four rules, your trap will stay empty:
- 1. Scent Control is Mandatory: Raccoons can smell human scent on metal. Always wear clean leather or nitrile gloves when handling the trap and the bait. Never touch the inside of the cage trap with your bare hands.
- 2. Target the Travel Path: Raccoons are creatures of habit. They follow the same invisible highways every night—usually along fence lines, the base of walls, or near water sources. Place the trap directly on this path.
- 3. Force Them to Commit: Place the bait at the absolute back of the cage trap. If you place it near the door, they will reach in, grab it, and leave without stepping on the trigger plate.
- 4. Check Your State Laws: In many states, relocating a raccoon is illegal due to disease spread (like rabies). Check your local Department of Natural Resources (DNR) laws before trapping.
Top 5 Raccoon Baits of 2026
1. Coon Gitter Bait (Best Overall)
If you want the gold standard for commercial raccoon bait, this is it. Coon Gitter is a dry pellet bait with a highly concentrated sweet cherry scent. Because it is dry, it doesn’t rot in the summer heat or freeze solid in the winter. The cherry scent is incredibly attractive to raccoons but is far less appealing to cats or dogs, making it a much safer choice in residential neighborhoods.
2. Pete Rickard’s Fish Oil (Best Long-Range Attractant)
Raccoons are scavengers, and fish is a natural part of their diet. Pete Rickard’s is a pure, concentrated fish oil. You don’t put this directly in the trap; you use it as a “trail lure.” Put a few drops on a cotton ball or a piece of wood 10 feet away from the trap. The scent carries on the wind and draws them straight to the trap.
The Catch: Cats absolutely love fish oil. If you are trapping in an area with outdoor cats, avoid this product.
3. Ringtail Cocktail Bait (Best Paste Bait)
A smoked salmon paste designed specifically for cage traps. Because it is a paste, you can smear it directly onto the trigger pan or the back wall of the trap. The smoking process gives it an intense, pungent odor that raccoons find irresistible, even if they are wary of the trap.
4. Dunlap Very Berry DP Coon Bait (Best for Dog-Proof Traps)
Dog-Proof (DP) traps are tubes that require the raccoon to reach in with its paw. You cannot use large foods like marshmallows in these. Dunlap Very Berry is a thick paste with an intense berry smell that you push down into the tube. It works flawlessly with DP traps and keeps stray cats completely safe.
5. Large Marshmallows (Best Household Bait)
If you have a raccoon on your porch right now and need to set a trap tonight, go to your kitchen. Large, full-sized marshmallows are one of the best baits on earth. The sweet smell draws them in, they are too big for the raccoon to pull through the wire without entering the cage, and cats and dogs typically ignore them. Place two or three at the back of the cage.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best bait for a raccoon?
For commercial bait, Coon Gitter (sweet cherry pellets) is the most consistently effective. For household food, large marshmallows are the best because they attract raccoons without drawing in cats, dogs, or skunks.
What food attracts raccoons the most?
Raccoons are highly attracted to sweet foods, fish, and fatty meats. Because their sense of smell is their primary hunting tool, scent-heavy baits (like fish oil or berry paste) vastly outperform plain foods.
How long does it take to catch a raccoon?
If the trap is placed on an active travel path and baited correctly, you can catch a raccoon the very first night. They are nocturnal, so check the trap first thing in the morning. If you catch nothing after three nights, move the trap to a new location.
Should I use peanut butter?
Yes, peanut butter is a highly effective household bait for raccoons. Smear a generous amount on a piece of bread or a cracker and place it behind the trigger plate.
What bait will NOT attract cats or dogs?
Sweet corn, large marshmallows, and berry-based commercial baits (like Dunlap Very Berry) are the most selective. They attract raccoons but are generally ignored by domestic pets.